The success rate
up to 90%
claimed for lie detectors is misleadingly attractive.
If we refer
a figure to a
company with 500 employees, twenty of
are thieves,
the lie detector could catch 18 of them, but in
so would place
32 innocent employees
suspicion. The
problem for the management would therefore become
of deciding
much industrial
unrest they
prepared to
cause in
to eliminate
theft. It seems surprising that a
more effective
way of using lie detectors has not
into fashion.
This method consists in
the subject to
read aloud statements about the crime
question.
Clearly, anyone who was not
of the true
facts would not
any distinction
between saying: 'The thief was
a sports jacket'
and 'The thief was dressed
a blue suit'.
a person who
knew the true facts would be likely to register a
reaction.
or not he
to disguise his
reaction, the method would ensure that an innocent
person could not be convicted in his place.